Microsoft Research Community
Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #9: Messy Desk - with Search!

If you're like me, you probably have a messy desk.

My desk piles up with papers that I expect to need again soon. There are tasks that I have started but not finished. There are also documents that I let stew on my desk because I want them to nag at my brain; I sense there's some important idea or insight lying in wait, but I haven't yet had the "Aha!" moment of how the information fits into everything else I am thinking about.

But according to Dr. David Kirsh, messy desks are really all about The Intelligent Use of Space.

Kirsh wrote a great paper of the same name where he discusses ways that people use physical space to simplify their tasks, as well as to facilitate opportunistic new uses for materials and tools. He calls the early stages of a project "the discovery phase."  He writes that:

In the discovery phase one wants to note as many possible extensions and variations to one's ideas as possible... Facilitating opportunism is to find a way of leaving equipment, intermediate products, and task detritus around the workplace.

In short, Kirsh concludes:

The most intelligent use of space is to try out conjectures... in the hope of triggering an association.

That's right, the detritus upon my messy desk really just represents my super intelligent use of space.

At least I hope that is the case. Or maybe it's just a mess. But I know once I clean up and put stuff in folders, I might as well dump it in the trash. The odds I ever touch any of those documents again-- or of getting to the root of that nagging feeling that the documents had important insights that I should learn from-- drops dramatically.

I like to think of InkSeine as the digital equivalent of my messy desk, a place for me to gather together the detritus of electronic work. But to make that useful, I need a really quick and easy way to get stuff into my notes in the first place.

With the advances that have been made in search technology, searches have become a big part of how I work. With standard search tools, I type in a query, my results are returned, and the query is forever gone. If I want to go back later and see how and where I found something, or to revisit the results to see if there is any new information, I am out of luck. It's just like those documents that I've filed way, never to be seen again.

And I don't just mean searching the web.

I have thousands of documents on my computer. I have over 18,000 emails in my inbox. I am totally dependent on search to put my hands on the information I need quickly. Doubly so on my Tablet PC, where tapping and double-tapping through folders can feel like trying to catch a fruit fly with a pair of chopsticks.

InkSeine offers the ultimate search scratchpad. Even on my desktop Wacom Cintiq display tablet, where I always have a keyboard ready to go, I rarely type in a query any more. A search in InkSeine is triggered directly from my notes, and it persists after I am done with it. I can remove it if I don't want it any more. But by default it gets created as its own object next to the ink that I use to start my query, and it gets saved in context with my notes.

It is extremely valuable to me to have all my searches persisted in this way. I'll keep all my searches with my notes about a project. Here's an example where I searched for the names of some people who have recently sent me some especially helpful feedback on InkSeine. I needed to collect all those together to make sure that our release plan would address as many of the issues as possible.

When I return to this page, I can just stroke down on any one of those search icons to see all the recent correspondence from that person. For example, Rob has kindly sent me some additional comments. I will go back to this note and use this search to see all his recent emails to me so I can add the remaining issues to my release plan. 

Anyway, I hope that all your InkSeine notes turn out to be messy ones, because I firmly believe that is the most intelligent use of (electronic) space.

 

Previous Post: Day #8: Collaborate on my Big Honkin Wacom Cintiq Tablet  

Next Post: Day #10: Scrapbook Fun!

 


Posted 01-30-2008 5:07 AM by Ken Hinckley
Filed under: , ,

Comments

feralboy wrote re: Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #9: Messy Desk - with Search!
on 01-30-2008 9:30 PM

Hey, I've been enjoying the hell out of these posts...but something I noticed -- you're still using XP! Shame on you!

Ken Hinckley wrote re: Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #9: Messy Desk - with Search!
on 01-31-2008 1:52 AM

Gack! I've been outed! A closet XP user! :-)

I actually use both XP and Vista. I have one hard drive with XP on it that I can pop into my main tablet PC, and another one with Vista. I've been using that tablet to test XP builds of InkSeine.

InkSeine definitely works best on Vista, but I am sure a lot of people with older tablets will be installing on XP, so we are trying to make sure everything works there too.

I use Vista on my big desktop Cintiq display. I love the improved handwriting recognition there. I get frustrated on XP because when I search for people's names it usually doesn't work on the first try. Vista picks those up from my email and the recognizer almost always gets them right. It's quite amazing.

I also have a Samsung Q1 UMPC with Vista on it. I was pleasantly surprised at how well Vista runs on that device; I thought it would be a dog, but the performance is quite reasonable. Some of the animations we do in InkSeine don't look that great on this UMPC though, I believe because the color-key and alpha transparency that we are using take a heavy toll on the processor. This is one issue that unfortunately has fallen off the stack for our initial public release - I already wasted too much time trying to make it look smoother/ better, without any success so far.

feralboy wrote re: Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #9: Messy Desk - with Search!
on 01-31-2008 9:55 PM

Okay, your job is safe for another year!

By the way, I think it's fantastic that you're taking the time to make sure things work on XP. My backup tablet PC (an old Toshiba R15) is still on XP so it's nice to know that I will be able to install it on both machines and create some parity in case I ever have to resort to the backup.

As for Vista's handwriting recognition, I believe it scours your Outlook contacts and adds what it finds to its dictionary, which is really quite smart. I've been very happy with my recognition results.

The AlpineInker wrote Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #11: Dish out a Little UMPC Love
on 02-01-2008 2:12 PM

I have a Samsung Q1 Ultra-Mobile PC. Originally I borrowed this to see if InkSeine would work correctly

Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #10: Scrapbook Fun - The AlpineInker wrote Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #10: Scrapbook Fun - The AlpineInker
on 02-01-2008 2:14 PM

Pingback from  Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #10: Scrapbook Fun - The AlpineInker

doc wrote re: Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #9: Messy Desk - with Search!
on 02-24-2008 2:39 AM

Can you explain how you're creating email and search links in InkSeine? I must be dense...or something while trying to figure out how to do this.

I figured how that I can drag a http link into it. When I try to drag an email, from Outlook 2007 using Exchange account, I just get the Ghostbusters logo in InkSeine.

Thank you, both for the great app, and in advance.

Ken Hinckley wrote re: Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #9: Messy Desk - with Search!
on 02-24-2008 3:04 AM

@doc: Sure thing. Right now, we do NOT support dragging emails directly out of Outlook onto an InkSeine page. But that feature would totally make sense. I remember Raman (InkSeine developer par excellence) investigated this at some point and there were a few gotchas, but I can't remember for sure what the issues were. We should revisit that. It would be awesome if we could get that working.

They way to do this, then, is to use the InkSeine 'Personal Search' feature to find the relevant email(s). Then you can drag them out of the search results list and onto your note page in InkSeine. Or try the 'Add To Notes' link when you tap on a result to get more detail - that's how I created those tidy rows of email links.

Ken Hinckley wrote re: Twelve Days of InkSeine, Day #9: Messy Desk - with Search!
on 02-24-2008 3:06 AM

I forgot to say, check out the InkSeine tutorial on search where the detailed steps are spelled out.

research.microsoft.com/.../tutorial-search-part-1.html

(visit page 6, the one before this one, if you want to see an overview of lasso selection, which is how you get the "green plus" context menu).

Twelve Days of InkSeine - The AlpineInker wrote Twelve Days of InkSeine - The AlpineInker
on 04-28-2008 2:58 AM

Pingback from  Twelve Days of InkSeine - The AlpineInker

©2009 Microsoft Corporation. All rights reserved. Terms of Use | Trademarks | Privacy Statement | Feedback